Citeseerx scenariobased analysis of software architecture. Finally, lessons and morals are presented, drawn from thee 4093 body of experience in applying scenario based architectural analysis techniques. Finally, lessons and morals are presented, drawn from the growing body of experience in applying scenariobased architectural analysis techniques. A structured method for scenario based enario based analysis is presented, using scenarios to analyze architectures with respect to419382 quality attributes. Sara makes use of failure scenarios that are prioritized with respect to the userperception in order to. We propose a software architecture reliability analysis sara approach that benefits from both reliability engineering and scenariobased software architecture analysis to provide an early reliability analysis of the software architecture. Pdf scenariobased software architecture evaluation methods. Scenario based architecture analysis offers a broad understanding of how a software reliant system evolves over time and can. The sei pioneered the use of scenariobased methods in the evaluation of software architectures for modifiability and other qualities.
For the past five years, software engineers at the software engineering institute sei have been using scenarios to guide in the design and analysis of soft. Scenariobased architecture analysis method how is scenario. Scenariobased software architecture evaluation methods. Mccall lists the following attributes as part of a quality software. To address to this problem we have defined a scenario based assessment technique saluta. The method explicitly addresses the quality attributes of the software architecture. Scenario based analysis of software architecture is increasingly seen as an elegant, costeffective means of controlling the risks inherent in architectural design 1.
In their case study report, they analyze lessons learned with this approach. Scenariobased safety analysis of software architectures. Architecture tradeoff analysis method atam 21 is a scenariobased software architecture evaluation method. Scenarios, usually written in natural language, have been widely used to represent a usercentric perspective of the system. Application of design combinatorial theory to scenario based. The tasks of an architect are alleviated if means can be provided to. This paper presents an experiential case study illustrating the methodological use of scenarios to gain architecturelevel understanding and predictive insight into large, realworld systems in various domains. Scenariobased analysis approaches have been widely applied and validated over the past several years. Pdf scenariobased analysis of software architecture.
The software architecture analysis method saam 20 was among the first to address the assessment of software architectures using scenarios. Scenariobased analysis of software architecture rick kazman department of computer science, university of waterloo waterloo, ontario gregory abowd college of computing, georgia institute of technology atlanta, georgia len bass, paul clements software engineering institute, carnegie mellon university pittsburgh, pennsylvania. Many practitioners argue that deriving supplementary visual models is an essential practice to understand. Scenariobased modeling is defined and explained within the greater context of requirements modeling for software engineering. Model driven architecture mda and its standards, model transformations and classifications, and mda tools support are also covered. Scenariobased generation and evaluation of software. Software architectures are described using a scenario based modeling technique called use case maps ucm 3,2. I wrote to the authors of scaling architecture evaluations within realworld constraints about my interest in finding reference material for the various software architecture evaluation methods like atam, cbam etc. Saam purpose saam creators looked for a method able to express the. Pdf scenariobased analysis of software architecture rick. Scenariobased analysis of software architecture core. Evaluating system architecture software engineering institute. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. The authors propose using scenarios to make analysis more straightforward.
Summary the following analysis takes a look at scenariobased usability engineering and software architecturebased design and the effects, if any, of each given design technique on software quality attributes as defined by mccall. As a result of our experience with architectural analysis, the prescribed steps. Scenario based analysis of software architecture rick kazman department of computer science, university of waterloo waterloo, ontario gregory abowd college of computing, georgia institute of technology atlanta, georgia len bass, paul clements software engineering institute, carnegie mellon university pittsburgh, pennsylvania. This makes effective software architecture evaluation methods essential in todays system development for mission critical systems. Software architecture reliability analysis using failure.
Scenariobased architecture analysis offers a broad understanding of how a softwarereliant system evolves over time and can. The development effort, the time and costs of complex systems are considerably high. In general, these analysis methods take as input the architecture design. The software engineering institute sei at carnegie mellon university has developed two scenariobased methodologies. We propose a software architecture reliability analysis approach sarah that benefits from mature reliability engineering techniques and scenariobased software architecture analysis to provide an early software reliability analysis at the architecture design level.
Saam was originally developed to enable comparison of competing architectural solutions 11. Software architecture is one of the most important tools for designingsi understanding a system, whether that system is in preliminary design, sign, deployment, or maintenance. Toward a discipline of scenariobased architectural. A creative approach to reducing ambiguity in scenariobased. Despite advances in clarifying high level design needs, analyzing a systems ability to meet desired quality criteria is still difficult. One of the most important issues in scenario based software architecture evaluation is the development of scenarios for characterizing a desired set of quality attributes by holding meetings of. Saam context saam is the first widely promulgated scenariobased software architecture analysis method. Toward a discipline of scenariobased architectural engineering. Software architecture and software design 2053 words bartleby. Software developers inevitably face the challenge of delivering software that meets the users requirements. Asaam aspectual software architecture analysis method 40 sacam software architecture comparison analysis method12 and dosam domain specific software architecture comparison model table 1.
Scenario based modeling is defined and explained within the greater context of requirements modeling for software engineering. One of the most important issues in scenariobased software architecture evaluation is the development of scenarios for characterizing a desired set of quality attributes by holding meetings of. Software analysis and evaluation becomes a wellestablished practice inside the architecting community of the software systems. They developed the software architecture analysis method, an approach that uses scenarios to gain information about a systems ability to meet desired quality attributes. The software architecture analysis method saam 20 was among the first to address the assessment of. Jan 17, 2018 in software engineering, a scenario describes an anticipated usage of a software system. Dec 16, 20 to address this question, we developed an approach to contextualize and focus the application of dependency analysis and architecture relevant code quality and system modifiability metrics using architecture evaluations. Summary the following analysis takes a look at scenario based usability engineering and software architecture based design and the effects, if any, of each given design technique on software quality attributes as defined by mccall. The sei pioneered the use of scenario based methods in the evaluation of software architectures for modifiability and other qualities. Architecture evaluation an overview sciencedirect topics.
In the requirements acquisition and analysis phase of software development, system. In order to assess systems quality against the requirements of its customers, the architects and the developers need methods and tools to support them during the evaluation process. The book discusses the discipline of software architecture using realworld case studies and poses pertinent questions that arouse objective thinking. One of the authors, zhao li, responded with a rather large list of references.
Although researchers have proposed various scenario based approaches to analyse software. Comparison of the various scenariobased evaluation methods evaluation method main objective steps in evaluation scenario classification. Scenario based software architecture reengineering abstract a method for reengineering software architectures is presented in this paper. It was created 3 to assess the architectures modifiability in its various names. Scenarios are important tools for exercising an3836269 in order to gain information about a systems fitness with respect to a set of. Use case and activity diagrams are also explained using examples. Our method builds upon research in the software architecture and software safety communities, and draws from the concepts of software architecture views ref. Architecture conception is a difficult and time consuming process, requiring advanced skills from the software architect. Abbreviation for scenariobased architecture reengineering sbar estimates the potential of the designed architecture to reach the software quality requirements. As scenarios are useful to understand the requirements and functionalities of a software system, the scenario based analysis is widely used in various tasks, especially in the design stage of software architectures. Scenario based architecture analysis method listed as saam. Scenariobased analysis of software architecture ieee software. Scenariobased analysis of software architecture ieee. In software engineering, a scenario describes an anticipated usage of a software system.
Finally, lessons and morals are presented, drawn from the growing body of experience in applying scenario based architectural analysis techniques. Pdf scenariobased software architecture evaluation. A structured method for scenariobased architectural analysis is presented, using scenarios to analyze architectures with respect to achieving quality attributes. Application of design combinatorial theory to scenario. Scenario based usability engineering and software architecture based design essay 2321 words 10 pages. The authors propose using scenarios to make analysis more s. Software architecture is one of the most important tools for designing and understanding a system, whether that system is in preliminary design, active deployment, or maintenance. Usually, the analysis is conducted manually in an adhoc fashion and scenarios. Scenariobased architecture analysis method listed as saam. Usability framework 3 software architecture assessment the design and use of an explicitly defined software architecture has received increasing amounts of attention during the last decade. To address this question, we developed an approach to contextualize and focus the application of dependency analysis and architecturerelevant code quality and system modifiability metrics using architecture evaluations. The first seideveloped architecture analysis method, the software architecture analysis method saam, introduced the concept of a quality attribute scenario, giving specific modifications against which the. Software architecture and software design 2053 words.
Scenario based analysis approaches have been widely applied and validated over the past several years. Ucm is a diagrammatic modeling technique to describe behavioral and to a lesser extent structural aspects of a system at a high e. Software architectures are described using a scenariobased modeling technique called use case maps ucm 3,2. What is requirements modeling requirements modeling uses a combination of text and diagrammatic forms to depict requirements in a way that is relatively easy to understand to validate software requirements, you need to examine them from a number of different points of view. Scenarios are important tools for exercising an architecture in order to gain information about a systems fitness with respect to a set. Jul 03, 20 scenario based analysis for large and complex software systems, specificuse cases are identified that represent the most important or most frequently occurring system usage scenarios, and the analysis is focused on those. A number of methods, such as architecture tradeoff analysis method atam 4 and architecturelevel maintainability analysis alma 5, have been developed to evaluate a systems software architecture with respect to desired quality. Scenariobased software architecture reengineering abstract a method for reengineering software architectures is presented in this paper. An approach for combining modelbased and scenariobased.
We propose a software architecture reliability analysis sara approach that benefits from both reliability engineering and scenario based software architecture analysis to provide an early reliability analysis of the software architecture. An approach for combining modelbased and scenariobased software architecture analysis conference paper pdf available august 2010 with 250 reads how we measure reads. Scenariobased analysis of software architecture november 1996 white paper gregory abowd, len bass, paul c. Scenariobased analysis for large and complex software systems, specificuse cases are identified that represent the most important or most frequently occurring system usage scenarios, and the analysis is focused on those. Despite advances in clarifying highlevel design needs, analyzing a systems ability to meet desired quality criteria is still difficult.
In this paper, we focus on software architecture analysis methods that utilize scenarios for evaluating architectures. The architecture of complex software systems is a collection of decisions that are very expensive to change. Home browse by title periodicals ieee software vol. This paper presents a sequence of steps that maps architectural quality goals into scenarios that measure the goals, mechanisms that realize the scenarios and.
A creative approach to reducing ambiguity in scenario. The goals of the method are to evaluate an architecture level design that considers multiple quality attributes and to gain insight as to whether the implementation of. Using scenariobased architecture analysis to inform code. Results include the impact on and risk of architectural choices for the system. In software architecture analysis, the architect often analyzes different scenarios that a system may experience during its lifecycle to ensure that all or most possible scenarios are covered in the design.
Software quality, software architecture analysis, applications of scenarios 1 introduction analysis of a proposed software system to determine the extent to which it meets desired quality criteria is desirable. We propose a software architecture reliability analysis approach sarah that benefits from mature reliability engineering techniques and scenario based software architecture analysis to provide an early software reliability analysis at the architecture design level. Assessment of quality attributes is performed primarily through the use of scenarios. This paper presents an experiential case study illustrating the methodological use of scenarios to gain architecture level understanding and predictive insight into large, realworld systems in various domains. As scenarios are useful to understand the requirements and functionalities of a software system, the scenariobased analysis is widely used in various tasks, especially in.
18 516 429 46 979 1123 212 275 1079 1300 1308 1447 241 651 309 1494 1183 1497 181 1279 700 177 738 100 728 814 1270 534 1065 854 388 1394 832 229 344 768 746 167 1405